Steam recently changed the default privacy settings for all users. This may impact tracking. Ensure your profile has the correct settings by following the guide on our forums.
If your profile is showing up as Not Ranked, please review our rules page and follow the appeal process detailed there.
I have just found that Dead Island for PS3 (I have not checked other platforms) appears with 61 total trophies instead of 59, so having all of them gives you a completion rate of 97%